From the Cool Cat Teacher Blog by Vicki Davis
Subscribe to the 10 Minute Teacher Podcast anywhere you listen to podcasts.
It seems like so much. It is the end of the school year, and we are being inundated with all of the rapid change.
Rapid change seems to be part of our lives.
And amidst the change are some pretty scary predictions. Some things that should outright concern us as humans.
Sometimes I think humans try to play god and forget we are just human. But we are that – humans. And in the desire of some to benefit themselves, they put their own pocketbook ahead of humankind.
Humans Matter, Your Voice Matters

But I’m a teacher. I’m also a woman of faith. I know Who is in control. It’s not me. And it is not you. And it isn’t even Sam Altman or any of the people who want to use AI to help us and then control us and then possibly rule us.
May it never be.
It is a battle for the future of humanity — or so they think. As if they think they can guarantee generational wealth and permanent success for themselves and their successors at the expense of everyone else. Like “nobody is going to have a job” but me. That is what is implied in everyone who says such a thing.
Mark my words, when I see an AI expert is anti-human, I run the other way.
A rising tide raises all ships. I want every school to do well. There are plenty of students, and we all need to help all of them succeed. Children are our future.
We need them to succeed. We need humans to succeed.
Because everyone goes the way of the earth – they die. But so few ever live. There’s a 100% death rate if you haven’t checked. I don’t say that to be a doomsayer, but rather to speak the truth. And we are accountable for what we do and how we do it in the time we have. And our time is short. And what we do with AI matters.
This means that our voices as teachers, administrators, and people working with kids are important. Now, more than ever.
The Nature of AI Requires We Have Conversations and Each Voice is Important
Because here’s the thing about AI:
- We all use it differently.
- It responds to each of us differently.
- It responds to our students differently.
And so we need to talk about it. We need to share our ideas about what we’re seeing with kids.
Some AI advocates seem to be worshiping it, some even seem to think it will save us. It won’t.

As I'm reading one of my “light” summer reading books, Agentic Artificial Intelligence: Harnessing AI Agents to Reinvent Business, Work and Life, they actually share how training agents takes more work because humans are required as intermediaries between the different agents. They discuss a situation in an ER that was using Agents but none of them talked to each other and ultimately the doctors and nurses stepped in and saved the person's life. Because right now AI agents have HUGE limitations and the authors make the point that the more important the decision, the more human supervision is needed.
Yes! See, we need humans.
I saw a student this past Sunday who had me two years ago – my first group of AI students. He’s in the Air Force and studying cybersecurity. When he gets his bars, he will return and see me, and meet with my class. He’s proud. And he should be.
But as I talked to him, his most significant problems aren’t AI. They are learning to work with people. How to resist the temptation to go down the rabbit hole of negativity that seems to cloud this generation.
You see, our biggest problems are very human. They always have been.
We've experimented on this generation by letting them grow up with social media and giving them phones so we could eat our lunch instead of teaching them how to act at the lunch table. Their brains are changing. Their attention is changing. And so teaching has changed very rapidly. But the old fashioned things still work.
I have two students in the last year who say I taught them one of the most important things in life.
Do you know what it is?
It isn't AI or computers or Python or ethics. It isn't prompting or app building or image generation.
It is showing up to class on time. Every day. Being dependable.
That one thing changed their lives.
Showing up.
So we need to show up right now at this time in history.
The Importance of Showing Up Right Now
But let’s be clear about this. Humans need to be supervising AI. AI should be accountable to us. It should be a tool that we use wisely. With supervision and discernment. We are accountable to one another and — if you believe like I do— to God – for how we teach and how we use this time in history.
It seems like there is a not-so-quiet desperation filling social media. It is palpable. And I refuse to fall into it.
Yes, AI is the issue that is shaping history. Like Web 2, it is full of promise. But people said Web 2 would make us grow closer, that it would improve understanding and give everyone a voice and make the world a better place. Instead, the inane useless stuff goes viral and the good people who do good things every day feel like their voice is too tiny to use. How did Web 2 work out for us? Did social media companies keep their promises? Just think about this – those of you who have lived a long time. Some good came from social media but it wasn't all good, was it? Not by a long shot! So the same is here. I can 100% guarantee that AI won't save us. The outcome of AI can't and won't all be good. It will be shaped by the flawed humans that brought it into existence. And they're not all good either. Quite the opposite. Absolute power absolutely corrupts. Always has. Always will.
So, here's where I am in this tiny little corner of the Internet.
I will do everything I can to share what I’m learning and elevate the voices of people who are also using AI in their CLASSROOMS.
And yes, teachers.
You are important.
Administrators — you too.
Sure, the world has room for consultants and many spent years in the classroom.
That is worth something.
Remember, just because a voice is loud doesn't mean it is right.
Some AI I had to stop using because it didn't save me time. IT MADE MORE WORK! Don't buy into the fact that all AI is a time saver. When I have a report on an important topic and 20% of the links are wrong, I now have to fact check and read every link. That didn't save me time – it made more work. I call boo on the “AI saves time” — not all AI saves time. But some of it does. And that's just the point. Speak up!
In my opinion, right now what is worth the most is the gold that comes from all of you who are in the classroom everyday. You might think your voice is tiny. But your voice matters. It is easy to feel tiny today in light of the challenges we face.
You who are struggling with the cognitive impact of a generation addicted to cell phones and connected with a million friends while eating alone at the lunch table. The kid who puts up their phone to try to learn math and hears a buzz in their backpack and you see their eyes flitting back and forth and their fingers flinching as they resist the desire to see who has notified them of something. It might be a like, a new video from their favorite influencer or even that their latest video they recorded on the way to school went viral. It might even be telling them to put a pencil in their Chromebook. You never know.
It could be anything.
But they are longing for something.
Something to show that their lives have meaning.
That living is worth it.
That they matter when they show up.
That they are a part of something special.
They are part of something special. It is called humankind.
Shame on the irresponsible people saying that we’re going to marry AI robots and we’re going to give AI control of the earth. Fools who don’t have a clue that the existence of of humanity matters to everyone who is… well… human. And that relationships between humans matter.
And so for me. I’m just going to take my summer.
I’m going to learn.
I’m going to rest and heal.
I’m going to laugh with dad and my husband and sisters and children.
I might even get a trip down the Nantahala River.
I’ll be writing on a book.
I’ll see some students – some of who are calling me for time or breakfast for advice. But there’s time for that.
You see, my students might follow a million influencers but to some of these kids, what I tell them matters more.
You see, I’m their teacher.
I teach with my life. I teach with my heart.
I learn so I can help them live better lives.
I refuse to join the freak out committee.
I also refuse to clamor and pretend like I have all the answers.
Someone who says they know it all is a liar.
AI doesn’t know it all.
We don’t know it all collectively.
And so one person can't know it all individually.
But I know this — as teachers, we’re better together.
Your voice matters. In fact it matters more today than tomorrow. Because this ship is still turning. Some incredible research is being done by some remarkable higher education researchers – but even in that, I read them and say — but “What about when I did this with my students?” Or that— “this doesn’t fit with this other tool I'm using.” (For example, so few researchers look at the power of Perplexity.ai which is far superior to Google search.)
And very few of these researchers talk about the times to put up devices. When to go lids down. And when to engage. The timeless truths of teaching are still here. AI and the Internet has a massive recency bias that will obfuscate the classical time-tested truths if we are forgetful.
And how many of these studies emphasize importance of helping kids show up? We can often make their backsides sit in a chair, but students determine whether to engage their mind. And the Hawthorne Effect (the resarch that shows that being researched improves outcomes) really rears its head these days because when people know they are being studied, they show up. Because they feel like it matters.
We have opportunities.
We have challenges.
We have problems – that is for sure.
But in all of this – I have hope.
I have hope because I know so many remarkable, loving, amazing teachers who are doing their best. And they are tired right now. Many of them stay tired.
But as they finish school or start summer (or are in the middle of the year as my friends in the southern hemisphere are) wherever they are and whoever they are, their job is important.
Some Things in Education Should Be Replaced
Let's be honest here, though. The teacher who just has kids memorize things and does worksheets all day — that is someone who may struggle to keep doing what they are doing. Because what they are doing is probably not working.
If there is something I'm doing that doesn't work. That pedagogy should be replaced. (And we're finding that AI writing lesson plans is actually taking us backwards in that arena.) Anyone who used an AI lesson plan generator saw it really wasn't usable except for sub plans (I wrote a custom gpt to take my personal lesson plans and turn them into sub plans in the format I like.) But the tiny voices either didn't speak or they weren't heard. How many times did I have to say “I can't use this to write my lessons” and I heard other teachers say it too! But we still hear “you can save time” writing lessons. And maybe some teachers do. And I look forward to hearing what they have to say.
But those who adapt and learn and grow, it can be a season full of meaning and timeless purpose. You were born for this time in history.
Teachers – you matter. You matter. Your students matter. Their parents matter.
Every human matters.
Your Voice Matters
AI matters because it will be shaped by humans — by the voices of humans — or, and this is what alarms me — the quietness of those good people who should be speaking but won’t and don’t.’
People who aren't speaking out might be saying in their minds – “I disagree, Vicki. What do I matter? This person is so well known. How dare I say something and end up looking stupid?”
I say. Ask your questions. They’re not dumb.
Sure, I’ll admit that so often I ask a question that I think is a good question based on classroom experience more often than not people answer my question by trying to make me feel stupid, like I don’t know how LLM’s work. But I do think I understand them well enough to ask questions. And the models are changing. And sometimes the person hasn't used the tools in the way I have. And I have experience in the furnace of kids are using AI in my classroom. I see what they are saying and doing. So, I think my tiny voice matters.
I see the kids who have personal accounts and hide it quickly b/c they don't want people to know what they are asking ChatGPT.
Sometimes we forget that AI is different to everyone and that each of us have a voice that matters. It is hard to put yourself out there. Here's the fact that — we’re all still learning. Your voice is needed.
AI-Induced Arrogance is a Problem

And the problem no one is really talking about is that this agreeable AI we're using right now is really good at breeding arrogance. No one has time to listen to tiny human voices because of the cacophony of words coming from their AI tool of choice. The one that is telling them “that's a good idea” or “great work” or “you're doing a great job.” The one that never ever says they are wrong. In fact, researchers have just shown that many AI models fail to recognize words such as no and not. This is a problem in the medical field right now. If it is looking for pneumonia, it finds it even if there is no pneumonia. So if it can't say no, when will it say – no that is a bad idea or, no I'm not going to do that for you? Or no, why will I weigh in on your decision to move your family across the country if. you haven't talked to your wife yet? There is a huge danger in using a tool hell-bent on convincing each of us we're brilliant and always right. Because we're not always brilliant. And we're not always right.
So we'd better wake up and listen.
We should choose to listen to the people that listen to teachers. Companies should build in feedback tools that are more than a thumbs up and thumbs down.
We should welcome teachers into the conversation about education.
We should not talk down to them or say “if you don't use this tool you're dumb.” or whatever they are excited about at the moment.
I know many people are excited but sometimes it feels like with AI that I'm listening to America's Got Talent and the judges are all saying “this is the best act I've ever seen.” And they've said it a thousand times and it just doesn't mean so much any more because I keep hearing it.
Yet, sometimes they are saying and noticing something different and we should listen even if we haven't seen that yet.
Likewise, we should listen to how people are using AI because they may have hit on something we haven't seen yet just because of the unique circumstances of their life and how they interact with a tool. Or maybe the tool is a new model. Or a new use case. Because AI learns every day. And it can change on you in a blink of a cursor.
Your Action Plan
Your voice matters. Parents. Teachers. Principals. Students. Authors. Grandparents.
We need to value human voices.
The people who have conversations.
The people who love kids.
And the people who love humans.
The people who actually write an answer themselves.
If you think you’re some kind of god who can transcend the travesty of not prioritizing humans, you don’t have a place speaking into my life.
I will use my tiny little voice – which also matters – to speak against anything that doesn't cherish humanity.
Because we matter.
Humans.
We matter.
And our thriving and success and joys and sorrows and living a great life — it matters too.
Those students said I taught them the most valuable thing — showing up.
Well I hope I'm teaching that to you. And reminding myself.
Show up.
So, as we face this time in history, I’ll use every single thing I have to tell you and encourage you to use your voice. Get your rest. And don’t ever let anyone tell you that you, your voice, your students, and you don’t matter. You do.
And I will fight until my hands are cold to promote and encourage teachers to reach every child. To show every child that they matter and that they have a purpose and that showing up is important.
We are still the noblest calling.
And no, AI did not approve this message or write a single word.
This is my voice.
And my voice matters too.
Imperfect, flawed, delightfully human voice.
And yours does too.
Because enough tiny little voices, when they work together. They become a choir. And when enough join in, they become a roar.
And I hope we will all add our tiny little voice to the AI conversations happening everywhere. We have two ears for a reason, so sure, we should listen twice as much as we speak. But if you're not speaking, you might not be listening either.
Listen. .
A tiny little voice just wrote her very human opinion. I ignored Grammarly telling me my sentences are too long. I ignored AI telling me my word choice was wrong. I admit I did fix (most) of my commas — and some typos. But I never ran this post through ChatGPT or Claude or Perplexity. I never asked AI what it thought or where the words dragged or went off track. I never asked AI where you would stop reading so I could “fix it.” AI would tell me nobody will read this. Maybe it would be right.
I don't care what it thinks.
I left in the humanity. Because even in a world where I'm learning to write agents, I'm using AI fields in airtable, and have written custom GPT's to use in my classroom and taught my kids the ethics of AI and all that goes with it. Even in that world.
My tiny voice matters.
And yours does too.
And I care what you think. I refuse to believe I'm the brilliant, all-wise, know it all AI seems to tell me I am. I'm human, after all. And human is awesome.
So what will you say with that beautiful, wonderful, human voice of yours? Let's talk.
The post A Tiny, Little Voice appeared first on Cool Cat Teacher Blog by Vicki Davis @coolcatteacher helping educators be excellent every day. Meow!
If you're seeing this on another site, they are "scraping" my feed and taking my content to present it to you so be aware of this.
from Cool Cat Teacher Blog
https://www.coolcatteacher.com/a-tiny-little-voice/